Warning: Your Influencer Marketing Agency Doesn't Do FTC Compliance

The influencer marketing industry has exploded over the past decade, but with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) cracking down on deceptive endorsements, the landscape is shifting dramatically. Many influencer marketing agencies claim to have compliance strategies in place, but the reality is stark: most don’t guarantee full compliance with the FTC’s strict new rules.

This oversight could leave brands exposed to hefty fines of $43,792 per violation and the reputational damage that comes with non-compliance.

The FTC’s Strict Stance on Influencer Marketing

The FTC’s new rules apply rigorous scrutiny to influencer marketing, emphasizing transparency and honesty. Key takeaways include:

1. Mandatory Disclosure: Influencers must clearly and conspicuously disclose material connections (e.g., paid partnerships, free products).
2. No Exaggerated Claims: Influencers can’t claim they’re “obsessed” with products they’ve barely used.
3. Fake Engagement is Fraudulent: Buying fake followers or likes to boost perceived influence is explicitly prohibited.

The Problem: Many agencies rely on outdated practices, leaving brands vulnerable to violations.

Why Most Agencies Don’t Guarantee Compliance

1. They Pay Influencers for Posts

Paying influencers to post is the most common practice in the industry, but it’s also the riskiest. The FTC scrutinizes paid posts heavily because they often lead to:

• Undisclosed sponsorships.
• Inflated or exaggerated claims about products.
• Posts that don’t reflect genuine consumer experiences.

Unless agencies move away from paying for posts altogether, brands face significant compliance risks.

2. They Don’t Enforce Proper Disclosures

Agencies may provide influencers with disclosure guidelines, but enforcement is often lax. Common problems include:

• Disclosures hidden in hashtags (#ad buried at the end of a caption).
• Vague language that doesn’t clearly signal a paid relationship.
• Inconsistent practices across platforms.

3. They Overlook Exaggeration and Virality

Influencers often exaggerate claims to drive engagement and shares. For example:

• Claiming they’re “obsessed” with a product they’ve only unboxed.
• Promoting unproven benefits like “instant results” without evidence.

Agencies that encourage or ignore these tactics are complicit in violating FTC rules.

4. Fake Metrics Slip Through the Cracks

Many agencies fail to audit influencer metrics for authenticity. Influencers who buy followers or engagement artificially inflate their value, misleading both brands and consumers.
Example: A brand pays an influencer based on their "500,000 followers," only to find that half are bots.

5. They Treat Compliance as an Afterthought

Compliance is often seen as a box to check rather than a core focus. Many agencies prioritize fast results over long-term legal safety, exposing brands to unnecessary risk.

What You Can Do

1. Demand Clear Compliance Guarantees

Work with agencies that guarantee FTC compliance and have a proven track record of managing campaigns ethically. Ask for transparency in their processes.

2. Audit Influencer Relationships

Ensure influencers are selected based on genuine engagement, not just follower counts. Use tools to verify authenticity.

3. Move Away from Paying for Posts

Consider alternatives like circular marketing, where influencers receive gated discounts for products they genuinely use and love. This model fosters organic advocacy and sidesteps many compliance pitfalls.

4. Enforce Strict Disclosures

Make sure all campaigns include disclosures that are:

• Clear and visible at the start of posts.
• Consistent across platforms.
• Tailored to FTC standards for different media types.

5. Monitor and Review Content

Implement approval processes to verify that influencer content meets FTC guidelines before it goes live.

Conclusion

Your influencer marketing agency may claim to handle compliance, but unless they address the root causes of FTC violations—paying for posts, fake metrics, and lax enforcement—they’re putting your brand at risk. In this new era of transparency and accountability, it’s time to rethink your approach to influencer marketing and demand more from your agency partners.

Key Takeaway: Compliance isn’t optional, and ignorance is no defense. Partner with agencies that prioritize ethical marketing practices and can guarantee FTC compliance.

‍